Is the AI boom an engine or a bubble? Federal Reserve Chairman Waller outlines three possible outcomes: a surge in productivity, massive unemployment, or a stock market crash.
Federal Reserve Chair Walsh stated that the rapid development of artificial intelligence technology could bring a surge in productivity and sustained growth to the US economy, but it may also lead to large-scale unemployment, and even a stock market decline and economic slowdown if investment returns fail to meet expectations.
According to Zhitong Finance APP, Federal Reserve Chairman Waller said on Monday that the rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI) technology could bring a leap in productivity and sustained growth to the U.S. economy, but could also trigger large-scale unemployment and, if investment returns fall short of expectations, lead to stock market declines and an economic slowdown. He emphasized that the impact of AI on the economy still carries significant uncertainty, and the Federal Reserve must prepare for different scenarios and assess potential implications for future monetary policy. Notably, Waller's speech did not directly address recent monetary policy nor provide new signals regarding the Fed’s future interest rate path. The three major U.S. stock indexes saw intraday losses widen, with the Nasdaq ultimately closing down 2.49% and the S&P 500 index closing down 1.92%.
Waller delivered his speech at a productivity and employment symposium hosted by the San Francisco Fed, outlining three scenarios for AI development that Federal Reserve staff are studying. He pointed out that AI could become a completely new economic and social force, with impacts distinct from previous technological revolutions, particularly in its unique potential to accelerate knowledge creation and the formation of new ideas.
In his remarks, he used the term “Super Intelligence” rather than the traditional “Artificial Intelligence.” This terminology is consistent with the executive order signed by U.S. President Trump in September this year, which requires federal government agencies to use “Super Intelligence” and its abbreviation “SI” in official communications.
In the most optimistic scenario, Waller believes widespread adoption of AI technology will significantly increase labor productivity, enabling businesses and workers to share in economic gains and pushing U.S. real GDP growth sustainably above the long-term average while maintaining near full employment.
This scenario also aligns with Waller's previous optimistic view of AI. He has repeatedly stated that productivity improvements driven by AI could help promote economic growth while easing inflationary pressures, creating a more favorable long-term development environment for the U.S. economy.
However, Waller also warned that productivity gains brought by AI may not translate into broad-based employment growth. In the second scenario, companies might dramatically reduce their demand for human labor through automation, resulting in a large number of jobs being replaced. Even if overall economic activity increases, the unemployment rate could still rise significantly.
The third scenario is even more concerning for financial markets: AI technology ultimately fails to deliver the high growth expectations held by investors and companies.
Waller pointed out that in the context of massive capital investment by companies and soaring stock markets driven by AI investment enthusiasm, if the expected returns of related projects start to decline, stock valuations may fall accordingly, triggering slower economic growth and a significant rise in unemployment rates.
He stated, “After large-scale capital investment and market rallies, expected returns may decrease, stock valuations may decline, leading to an economic slowdown and more pronounced increases in unemployment.”
Waller added that in such a situation, the economy would eventually recover, but the previously anticipated productivity improvements may not materialize.
In recent years, the development prospects of AI technology have driven up technology stock valuations and prompted companies to raise funds through equity and debt to support data center, computing infrastructure, and related technology R&D. The third scenario proposed by Waller highlights the potential market concerns about the sustainability of AI investment returns and valuations.
Nevertheless, he emphasized that the above three scenarios are not official Federal Reserve forecasts for the future economic outlook, but rather help policymakers understand the possible outcomes of technological change. “Our responsibility is to prepare for whatever may happen in the future.” Waller stated that the Federal Reserve's role on this issue is neither advocacy nor opposition, but to recognize that the widespread adoption of new technologies will have a significant impact on the economy and may have important implications for future monetary policy.
He pointed out that the most critical questions now concern the extent, scope, and timing of AI's impact on the economy.
In fact, the impact of the AI boom on the economy has already started to emerge, but short-term effects may differ from long-term expectations. Waller previously believed that productivity growth driven by AI was expected to curb inflation while promoting economic expansion. However, at an event hosted by the IMF in Bangkok this October, he admitted that the prices of materials and other inputs needed for AI infrastructure construction have risen sharply, putting pressure on overall inflation.
He pointed out at the time that the AI investment boom has clearly stimulated demand side activity first, while its positive impact on supply will take longer to manifest.
The latest data shows that U.S. labor productivity in the third quarter grew at an annual rate of 3.6%, the fastest pace in a year. However, economists believe that the direct contribution of AI to productivity improvement is still relatively limited.
This means that although AI is expected to boost economic efficiency in the long term, before large-scale technology investment turns into actual productivity growth, related capital outlays may also drive up resource demand and price levels, complicating monetary policy decisions.
To further study these issues, after taking office as Fed Chairman in June this year, Waller announced the establishment of five working groups led by external experts to research topics including productivity and employment, Fed communications, data reliance, balance sheet policy, and the inflation framework.
Of these, the working group studying the impact of AI on productivity and employment is led by famous venture capitalist and Andreessen Horowitz co-founder Marc Andreessen. Other members include Microsoft (MSFT.US) Xbox CEO Asha Sharma and Stanford University scholar Charles Jones.
Monday’s symposium brought together tech company executives, economists, academics, and Fed officials to discuss AI’s potential influence on U.S. economic growth, the labor market, and productivity. Participants included Fed Governor Cook, Stanford University economist Nick Bloom, and Palo Alto Networks (PANW.US) Chairman and CEO Nikesh Arora, among others.
Some attendees believed that the U.S. economy could continue to outpace other countries due to its advantage in adopting new technologies. However, some experts were concerned that excessive reliance on AI tools by students might undermine their independent learning abilities.
Waller previously stated that these working groups are expected to make policy recommendations by the end of this year, which will then be submitted to the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) responsible for monetary policy decisions for further study.
He stated that AI is ushering the economy into a new stage of development, but it remains uncertain whether it will ultimately bring stronger growth, more severe employment shocks, or a market adjustment after unmet investment expectations. For the Federal Reserve, identifying the true impact of this technological transformation on economic growth, employment, and inflation will become a key challenge for future monetary policy making.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
Bridgewater shifts toward AI hardware and energy in Q3: heavy holdings in Nvidia and Broadcom, increased positions in Micron and SanDisk, reduced holdings in Google and Amazon
As of September 30, Bridgewater disclosed a total of 974 investment positions with a total market value of $23 billion. In the third quarter, it initiated new positions in Dominion Energy, Occidental Petroleum, and Cisco, while significantly increasing holdings in Micron Technology, SanDisk, Qualcomm, Qorvo, and AppLovin. It reduced holdings in the three major S&P 500 Index ETFs as well as Google A and Amazon, and fully exited positions in Union Pacific, Paccar, and S&P Global.
AI sector sell-off continues! Nasdaq 100 falls for three consecutive days, Nvidia (NVDA.US) extends drop by over 4%
U.S. tech stocks extended their decline on Monday as investors remained cautious about AI-related investments ahead of Nvidia's upcoming earnings report and the planned IPO of AI startup Anthropic later this week.
Cleveland Fed President Advocates Gradual Rate Hikes, Warns Rising Inflation Expectations May Force Central Bank to Intensify Tightening
Hammack stated that she prefers to gradually tighten monetary policy through a series of small interest rate hikes, but if inflationary pressures intensify further, the Federal Reserve may have to accelerate the pace of rate hikes or even implement larger increases, raising rates above previously expected levels.
Overnight US Stocks | All Three Major Indexes Fall, Nvidia (NVDA.US) Continues to Drop Over 4%, Reportedly No Intention from Board to Reinstate Jensen Huang as CEO
At the close, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 739.37 points, or 1.41%, to 51,608.17; the S&P 500 Index dropped 145.08 points, or 1.92%, to 7,416.59; and the Nasdaq dropped 626.51 points, or 2.49%, to 24,509.75.
