Bitget App
Trade smarter
Buy cryptoMarketsTradeFuturesStocksEarnInstitutionAI & More
"Boredom is Beauty"? BTIG: The Unusual Strength of Defensive Sectors Reminds People of the Eve of the 2000 Bubble Burst

"Boredom is Beauty"? BTIG: The Unusual Strength of Defensive Sectors Reminds People of the Eve of the 2000 Bubble Burst

华尔街见闻华尔街见闻2026/11/16 13:36
Show original
By:华尔街见闻

In the past 30 days, the S&P 500 Consumer Staples sector outperformed the Technology sector by 33 percentage points, marking the largest monthly gap in nearly 25 years and echoing the defensive rotation characteristic seen before the bursting of the internet bubble in 2000. BTIG strategist Krinsky is optimistic about Consumer Staples and warns that Technology stocks and semiconductors still have room for further declines, with a strong US dollar potentially exacerbating liquidity pressures. However, there is still disagreement in the market on whether this rotation can persist, with the focus shifting to whether AI-related trades have entered a prolonged adjustment period.

Toothpaste, biscuits, cigarettes, and bourbon whiskey are outperforming AI trades.

Over the past 30 days, the S&P 500 Consumer Staples sector has outperformed the Technology sector by 33 percentage points—the largest single-month gap in roughly 25 years. BTIG Chief Technical Strategist Jonathan Krinsky pointed out that the last time a similar pattern emerged was from April 2000 to October 2001—right at the outset of the bursting of the internet bubble. Meanwhile, the tech ETF QQQ has fallen below its highest trading volume range of the past two years, meaning any rebound may face heavy selling pressure from trapped positions.

In his latest weekly report "Boredom is Beautiful," Krinsky stated clearly that he has become "bullish" on the consumer staples sector. The consumer staples ETF (XLP) has broken out of a multi-month consolidation, with both its absolute price action and its ratio relative to the S&P 500 breaking higher simultaneously. He characterizes this combination of "negative sentiment and strong price action" as a "powerful long signal." Meanwhile, the US Dollar index is breaking out to two-year highs, which Krinsky calls "one of the most bullish charts in the market right now," while a strong dollar has historically been unfavorable for risk assets.

The unusual strength of these defensive sectors is raising profound doubts about the sustainability of AI trades in the market. If history from 2000 is repeating, the correction for tech stocks may have only just begun, while the so-called "boring stocks" shunned by the market might be entering an early stage of prolonged rotation.

Consumer staples outperform tech by 33%—A 25-year record

The impact of the data cannot be ignored.

According to Krinsky, in the past 30 days, consumer staples have delivered 33 percentage points of excess return over tech—a record monthly gap in almost a quarter century. Just two weeks ago, the consumer staples sector recorded its strongest single-month performance since October 2000.

At that time, even consensus among banks like Bank of America was that defensive sectors had rallied into a 1999-style bubble zone, with even "safe assets" appearing overheated. However, Krinsky has changed his perspective. His core logic is: When a stock is considered "expensive" with little growth yet continues rising, the market itself is sending a message.

"Investors often want to buy cheap, sell expensive... The consensus on consumer staples is that they're 'expensive' and have limited growth. That may be true, but it was also said a month ago, and since then they've risen 10%. Sometimes the market is wrong, but sometimes it's telling a story worth listening to," Krinsky wrote in his report.

XLP has broken above a multi-month consolidation, with the XLP/SPX ratio breaking out at the same time. Krinsky considers this combination of "negative sentiment and strong price action" a "strong long signal" and notes that the sector isn't yet significantly overbought, so further upside remains.

The Mirror of 2000: Tech collapse, defensive sectors surge

Krinsky has previously warned of "echoes of the internet bubble," and now again references that period as a guide.

The Nasdaq peaked on March 10, 2000, but the ensuing bear market did not sweep through all sectors at once. According to BTIG data, from March 10, 2000, to March 10, 2001, consumer staples rose 50.3%, utilities rose 44.0%, and the financial sector was up 36.4%; meanwhile, technology plunged 56.9%, and the S&P 500 "only" fell 11.6%. In other words, the index's drop was mild, but the typical investor saw their positions nearly halved.

Compare that to today: Since the AI trades topped around June 22, healthcare is up 25.0%, energy 19.7%, consumer staples 12.6%; meanwhile, tech is down 7.3%, while the S&P 500 is up a modest 0.6%. The sector divergence looks highly similar to that seen in 2000.

Krinsky also notes some differences: In 2000, many sectors had already dropped 20% to 30% before the March 10 peak, so today's extremity isn’t as severe. But he emphasizes that "the leadership of defensive sectors is hard to ignore." Overlaying consumer staples' performance against tech's, the 2000 chart and today's are nearly identical.

Even more unsettling for AI bulls: After the initial rotation in 2000, consumer staples continued to outperform tech by nearly 1,000 basis points over the next two years. The first rotation was dramatic, the subsequent outperformance was a long, slow grind.

Tech stocks: Trapped supply overhead, semiconductors may fall another 17%-25%

Technical pressure on tech stocks is likewise troubling. Krinsky’s QQQ volume profile shows that price is now below the densest trading range of the past two years, meaning any rebound faces heavy overhead supply—last Thursday’s failed rally confirmed this view.

The situation is even tougher for semiconductors. SOXX is pinned below a supply zone, and Krinsky maintains his earlier view that it needs to pull back to the April breakout level, leaving "about 17% to 25% downside from current levels."

At the same time, Apple (AAPL)—seen as a "defensive alternative" within tech—has also flashed caution. The stock is up 31% year-to-date, but after posting new 52-week highs last Thursday and Friday, it closed down more than 1% each day—the same pattern seen November 4 and 5.

Krinsky, looking back over 20 years of data, found only 9 similar instances—consecutive two-day 52-week highs with each close down more than 1%. In the following 20 trading days, returns were negative 89% of the time, with an average drop of 12.57% and a median of -8.97%. The sample is small, but the direction is consistent: "Apple has been a safe haven, but with the stock up 31% this year and showing exhaustion signals, we think it’s quite vulnerable to downside reversion in the coming weeks."

The dollar breaks out of a two-year range, liquidity tightening weighs on AI trades

Connecting the rotation between these sectors is a macro driver: the US Dollar.

The Bloomberg Dollar Index is breaking above a two-year range high. Krinsky calls it "one of the most bullish charts in the market right now, but potentially damaging to risk sentiment." GBP/USD, AUD/USD, CAD/USD, and NZD/USD have all retreated from recent highs, and the NZD has already broken support.

Bank of America strategist Michael Hartnett voiced similar concerns this week, warning that if the dollar "continues to spike like this, it will become a destructive force." Goldman Sachs’ FX team reportedly expects another dollar rally before a reversal in 2027.

A strong US dollar means global liquidity is tightening. And liquidity tightening historically hits the most crowded and leveraged parts of the market hardest—right now, that's AI trades.

It’s worth noting that consumer staples, a classic substitute for bonds, have managed to break out even as the 10-year Treasury yield closed at 5.15% and markets expect three more Fed hikes. Krinsky believes this suggests the inflows into consumer staples are mainly driven by a search for safety from AI trades—dividend yield is a secondary factor.

Rotation or trap? Disagreements persist

Not everyone agrees with this view. In the latest Bank of America "Flow Show" report, Hartnett listed "mega-cap consumer stocks" as among the most vulnerable if dollar and liquidity pressure intensify, while calling discretionary consumer stocks the most likely to deliver positive surprises over the next eight weeks—exactly opposite to the relative performance ratios Krinsky is tracking. One of them will be wrong.

Krinsky himself remains cautious. He expects that as the overall market falls, sector correlations will rise, and consumer staples "will not be completely immune to a broad selloff." Regarding the equal-weight ratio of consumer staples to consumer discretionary (RSPS/RSPD), he says, "It's too early to say this is a new uptrend," but if the ratio breaks 0.58, "that will be significant." Last Friday’s close was at 0.569, about 2% away from a breakout.

At the heart of this debate is a classic market question: Is the strength in defensive sectors the beginning of a prolonged rotation, or just a crowded defensive trade about to be neutralized by rising correlations? If 2000 is any guide, the bear market in tech could last far longer than bulls expect; and even if consumer staples fall 5%, if semiconductors drop another 20%, staples would still outperform by 15 to 20 percentage points. As some in the market say: When investors can’t understand a tech bubble, they buy into ‘soap bubbles’.

0
0

Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.

Understand the market, then trade.
Bitget offers one-stop trading for cryptocurrencies, stocks, and gold.
Trade now!

You may also like

Amidst the semiconductor plunge, are AI "landlords" gaining favor? Blackstone Data Center REIT (BXDC.US) rises over 10% pre-market as long-term cash flow becomes the market focus

Blackstone Digital Infrastructure Trust has acquired a majority stake in two joint ventures established with Amazon Web Services for approximately $5 billion. BXDC will own 13 newly built powered buildings in two AWS data center campuses. AWS will lease back the entire portfolio of buildings, with an initial lease term of 12 years, extendable to 32 years.

智通财经•2026/11/16 13:40

Jensen Huang steps down, Nvidia (NVDA.US) money becomes "cautious": $500 billion may only be invested in major companies in the future

After Jensen Huang's departure, Nvidia's $500 billion AI financing platform is expected to continue, but may be paused in the early stages. The cost of new deals will rise, and funds may shift from emerging cloud providers to more established large-scale cloud companies.

智通财经•2026/11/16 13:22
Jensen Huang steps down, Nvidia (NVDA.US) money becomes "cautious": $500 billion may only be invested in major companies in the future

Philadelphia Semiconductor Index Rebound "Stalls": Technicals at Risk, Could NVIDIA (NVDA.US) Earnings Be the Final Straw?

In the calculations of technical analysts' charts, the market is never random noise, but rather a repeated contest between support and resistance levels. Now, the balance of this contest is quietly tilting in favor of the bears.

智通财经•2026/11/16 13:07
Philadelphia Semiconductor Index Rebound "Stalls": Technicals at Risk, Could NVIDIA (NVDA.US) Earnings Be the Final Straw?

What you think is diversified holdings is actually all betting on AI? Wall Street starts to penetrate AI risks, seeking cash flow winners

Until recently, investors regarded artificial intelligence as one of the biggest bets in Wall Street history. Now, many portfolio managers are more cautious about this field and are trying to assess just how much AI risk exists within their portfolios. There is a lot at stake. According to the MSCI Global Think Tank Index, at least $25.3 trillion is invested in the world’s largest companies that are directly related to artificial intelligence. In addition, there are countless other investments that are difficult to quantify—companies that could either benefit from or be harmed by the way AI is reshaping various industries.

智通财经•2026/11/16 13:05
What you think is diversified holdings is actually all betting on AI? Wall Street starts to penetrate AI risks, seeking cash flow winners